
First of all, I want it to be known that I am both a knitter and a crocheter. I love both crafts, and they each have their positives and negatives. There seems to be a great division between the two parties, or at least that is the perception. One craft is often held in higher status than the other, and in my opinion this tendency is completely arbitrary.
Knitting and crocheting are two very different ways of making a piece of fabric, since the execution of the individual stitches requires the use of either two needles (in the case of knitting), or one hook (in the case of crochet). This doesn't mean that one way is superior (or inferior) to the other. It simply means that one method produces results that look and feel one way, while the other produces results that have their distinctive look and feel. Are there differences? Yes, of course there are. Are there differences between a Mac and a PC? Of course. You'll find devotees of both. There are some things that one does better than the other, and vice versa. It's the same with knit and crochet. Crocheting uses approximately one-third more yarn than knitting, and that is one difference which you'd think might make yarn manufacturers very happy, but doesn't seem to. Knitting produces fabric with a very nice drape, well-suited to wearable items like sweaters and lacy shawls. Crochet, however, tends to make heavier afghans, extremely cozy and warm hats, and when done with sport weight (or lighter) yarn, can make quite beautiful sweaters and jackets that can stand their own up against the finest of hand-knits.
I endorse both crafts, as each one has its special place in the world of handwork. Some people just prefer one over the other, and that's fine. Some learned to knit from the beginning, fell in love with it, and just never ventured into crochet, for whatever reason. Others first learned to crochet and stayed put with hook in hand. That, too is fine.
I want to propose a challenge to all the knitters and crocheters of this world: Give the other one a try. If you've never produced a stitch in your life on two needles, give it a try. If you've never looped yarn through hook, give it a try. If you still feel a bit snobbish toward one particular craft, then practice the opposing one at home where no one can see you. And please, don't just pick up the other craft and try casting on or making a starting chain and then leaving it there. No. Finish a project and see how your work turns out. Knit an entire scarf. Crochet a hat to completion. Give it your best shot. If you need help, get a friend to show you, or better yet, grab an instructional video or DVD to guide you. There are tons of them available, and some of those video teachers were my best friends in my hours of desperation.
Try both crafts. Give them your best efforts. Put yourself in the other crafter's place and see for yourself what it's like to "cross over to the other side." You just might find you enjoy both ways of making things, and you might find your preferred uses for each one. They are both lots of fun, speaking from my experience, and both present unique challenges. I've learned a lot by learning both, and who knows, I might even try tatting or embroidery next! Maybe.



